Indigenous skills vital to conservation research outcomes
Dr Georgia Ward-Fear with Balanggarra rangers, brothers Herbert (left) and Wesley Alberts, about to release 'Barney', a large goanna. Photo by Melissa Bruton.
Ìę
Researchers at the University of Sydney have produced hard data that demonstrates collaborating with Indigenous peoples changed the outcome of a scientific research project. It is the first empirical evidence that culturally diverse teams produce improved results in conservation research.
, a conservation biologist and herpetologist (amphibians and reptiles), said this was the first published study to measure the scientific contribution that Indigenous peoples bring to a research project, beyond the moral or ethical value.
âThis is of major importance for Indigenous peoples around the world,â Dr Ward-Fear said. âTraditional owners often donât have a voice in science. This is a case study for Indigenous groups globally to hold up and say âwe deserve a voiceâ and âwe deserve input into researchâ.â
James âBirdyâ Birch, a leading ranger from the in the Kimberley said: âThe university-educated scientists have research tools, data and methods that work for them. But we have every-day lived experience. We have knowledge of the land and the animals passed down over thousands of years. If we put these skills together, it paints a clearer picture.â
Dr Georgia Ward-Fear working with Wesley Alberts.
Working with traditional owners of the land
Dr Ward-Fear, from the , and her team have been working in the Kimberley, a remote area of northern Western Australian. Her conservation work involves protecting large goannas from the devastating impacts of invasive, poisonous cane toads.
Over 18 months, teams made up of a Western scientist and an Indigenous ranger would set out at daybreak to find and capture the goannas â which can grow up to 1.7 metres in length and weigh more than six kilograms. They fitted the lizards with radio transmitters and then released them and trained them to avoid eating the large toads. They did this by approaching the animal in the field, and feeding the goanna a small toad, large enough to make them sick but not kill them. This put the lizards off eating the toads once the invasion arrived.
The aversion training, developed with , has been hugely successful and is now being rolled out on a large scale via , a consortium of scientists, government authorities, conservation groups and the Australian Research Council.
But Dr Ward-Fear said the success of the initial project would not have been possible without the input of the Balanggarra Rangers, who are traditional owners of the land.
âWorking with Indigenous rangers, you get to see their unique skillsets. Once we showed that the trial worked, I was curious to see whether this contributed to the success of the study in a way we could quantify,â Dr Ward-Fear said.
âEven though we worked in teams and had the same opportunity to spot the lizards, there were significant differences in the animals that the rangers spotted,â Dr Ward-Fear said. âThe rangers have amazing observation skills and ability to see animals in a landscape. They could see the shape of a goanna when they were not moving, were in the shade or dappled light or from much further away. The Western scientists tended to see animals that were closer, out in the open or moving.â
Goannas balance on their hind legs and tail to sniff the air when they are foraging for food.
Published today in , the study found the Indigenous rangers were able to find and collect a subset of large varanid lizards (goannas) that Western scientists were unable to spot. Importantly, these lizards displayed different behavioural profiles throughout the study: they were more âshyâ than the bolder lizards foraging in broad daylight; and they also learned the aversion technique better than the braver lizards.
âThese ranger-spotted animals responded better to the conservation technique and they actually drove the significant result of the study,â Dr Ward-Fear said. âIf we hadnât worked with rangers and we hadnât collected that subsample of animals then our results wouldnât have been significant.â
"We could see them miles away," said James 'Birdy' Birch.
Photo above and main photo of the four rangers by Kimberley Land Council.
Local knowledge
James âBirdyâ Birch is the head ranger with the Balanggarra Rangers. He said the rangers had unique skills to offer the scientists.
âWe had access to country for a start,â Mr Birch said. âWe knew where the goannas were and we caught over 100 of them. We just had a keen eye. We could see them miles away.
âMy rangers all grew up on this country hunting for goanna with their parents. It is knowledge passed down for thousands of years.â
Mr Birch believes science can benefit from combining the two âways of lookingâ.
âYouâve got the Western way of looking with all the tools and the data, and youâve got the Indigenous way of looking at things. Together, Western science and Indigenous knowledge, they complement each other. Weâve got our skills and you guys have got your skills, we can put them together and find out so much, we were amazed by the results.â
Dr Ward-Fear said the scientific community already knows it is ethical to work with the traditional owners of the land. âBut now we know there is ethical and scientific value in working together in meaningful collaborations,â she said.
The conservation research team consisted of five scientists from the University of Sydney and five Indigenous rangers from the .